|
NOTE
TO EDITORS: Biologist Denise Dearing will be available to reporters
and camera crews at 1 p.m. MST Saturday Feb. 10 in the ground-level
(2nd floor) foyer of the Skaggs Biology Bldg. Enter door under sky
bridge on west side of building. Contacts: Denise Dearing, biologist
- office (801) 585-1298 Lee Siegel, university science news specialist
- cell (801) 244-5399, office (801) 581-8993
February 10, 2001 –University
of Utah biologists found nearly 30 percent of deer mice were infected
with hantavirus around central Utah sand dunes popular with people
who ride off-road vehicles (ORVs).
The scientists
said more research is needed to determine if the high infection
rate among deer mice near the federal Bureau of Land Management's
Little Sahara Recreation Area was caused by ORV traffic that has
created dirt roads and trails. They theorize that when ORVs denude
rodent habitat, the animals are crowded into remaining areas of
vegetation, leading to increased fighting, biting and scratching
that allows the virus to be spread among mice when saliva and blood
enter their wounds.
"We found an
unusually high prevalence of hantavirus in deer mice we caught near
the Little Sahara Recreation Area in central Utah," said Rachel
Mackelprang, the study's principal author and a senior in biology
at the University of Utah. "Given the previous research and all-terrain
vehicle use, the unusually high prevalence could be due to the habitat
being disturbed by off-road vehicles."
"It's a hypothesis
we need to test," said study co-author Denise Dearing, an assistant
professor of biology at the university. "From what we know about
small-mammal ecology and transmission of hantavirus, it seems that
human disturbance [of the landscape] could alter transmission of
hantavirus" among rodents.
Dearing said
researchers simply do not know if increased prevalence of hantavirus
among mice raises the risk of transmission to humans. Mackelprang
said she doubts there is any increased danger to the thousands of
people who camp and ride ORVs in the area. "We presume the danger
to people camping there is minimal because hantavirus is transmitted
to humans as an aerosol" or dust that people inhale when mouse feces
or urine become airborne, Mackelprang said. "Humans usually get
it in enclosed spaces like a garage or basement they are sweeping
out. If you are outdoors, there is no chance of breathing such concentrated
dust."
Mackelprang
said ORVs usually kick up sand from areas denuded of vegetation,
rather than creating finer dust or aerosol particles from vegetated
areas inhabited by the mice.
Nevertheless,
Dearing added, "without further research we really don't know how
higher prevalence [of hantavirus in deer mice] will affect people
in the outdoors."
The study by
Mackelprang, Dearing and Stephen St. Jeor, a virologist at the University
of Nevada, Reno, has been accepted for publication in the May-June
issue of the journal Emerging Infectious Diseases, but is expected
to appear in the journal's online edition in the next week or so.
The journal is published by the federal Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention (CDC).
The hantavirus
in the mice at Little Sahara is a strain known as the Sin Nombre
virus, which was identified as the cause of an outbreak of potentially
deadly hantavirus pulmonary syndrome (HPS) that was first recognized
in May 1993 in the Four Corners states of Utah, New Mexico, Arizona
and Colorado.
From the time
of that outbreak through Dec. 7, 2000, 277 cases of hantavirus pulmonary
syndrome have been reported in the United States, and 38 percent
resulted in death, according to the CDC, which listed a total of
14 cases in Utah.
Data for the
new study were collected when Mackelprang and Dearing trapped deer
mice, wood rats (also known as packrats), pinyon mice, kangaroo
rats, pocket mice and sagebrush voles in non-dune areas around Little
Sahara during three seasons in 1999: May 29-31, July 10-12 and Oct.
7-9. Those areas are riddled with dirt roads and trails from ORVs,
and often provide unimproved campsites for people unable to find
space at official campgrounds.
The biologists
set up three live animal traps at about 40 wood rat nesting sites
called middens, which are 7-foot-diameter, 2-foot-high mounds made
of thousands of sticks. The traps were baited with oats, peanut
butter and cotton, which rodents like as nesting material.
Captured rodents
were anesthetized briefly so blood samples could be obtained. St.
Jeor tested the blood samples for the presence of antibodies to
hantavirus. In some viral diseases, antibodies indicate past infection
but not necessarily current infection. Deer mice infected with hantavirus
remain infected chronically, so the antibodies indicate which mice
are infected, Dearing said.
Of 212 deer
mice captured during the three trapping periods, the antibody test
indicated 63 were infected, for a prevalence of 29.7 percent. That
was almost three times greater than the infection rate found in
other studies of similar habitats within the Great Basin of Utah
and comparable to the infection rate seeing among deer mice in areas
where the 1993 hantavirus pulmonary syndrome outbreak happened,
Dearing and Mackelprang said.
The study also
found hantavirus antibodies in four of 37 pinyon mice that were
tested, or 10.8 percent, although the biologists do not know if
the deer mice spread the virus to pinyon mice or vice versa. Hantavirus
infection was not found in other species at Little Sahara, including
the wood rats.
Mackelprang
and Dearing cite several arguments to support the hypothesis that
disturbance of the landscape by ORVs may be responsible for the
high prevalence of hantavirus among deer mice around Little Sahara.
First, studies
in Kansas and Europe have shown that when rodent habitats are disturbed
- either by roads or when fields are mowed to create unmowed "islands"
of grassy habitats - the density of deer mouse population increases
dramatically. Second, those studies show deer mice in such fragmented
habitats travel farther than mice in undisturbed areas.
Third, other
research has shown small rodents living in denser populations become
more susceptible to infection than rodents that are less crowded.
Fourth, an earlier CDC study found only 11 percent of deer mice
were infected with hantavirus in four other Great Basin sites with
habitat similar to the scrub and pinyon-juniper habitats around
Little Sahara.
Dearing said
the researchers did not set out to study how ORV use affects hantavirus
prevalence in rodents, but instead chose to study Little Sahara
because wood rats occupy the area and, in previous work, Dearing
had found that wood rats there sometimes carry hantavirus.
Mackelprang
said she is an inactive member of the Sierra Club, and Dearing has
donated to environmental groups. Both believe there should be a
balance between protecting fragile landscapes and having land available
for enthusiasts who enjoy riding ORVs such as trucks, dune buggies,
motorcycles and small three- and four-wheeled all-terrain vehicles
(ATVs). But they said their study is not an effort to combat ORV
use.
"We want to
emphasize we are not on a vendetta against ATVs," Mackelprang said.
"This is just what we found, and a hypothesis that seems to fit
the data."
Dearing said
that if scientists can learn how transmission of hantavirus is affected
by human disturbances to the landscape, "maybe we can do things
to reduce transmission to humans. For example, when people put a
cabin in the woods, if they clear the area around the cabin [for
fire safety] and then deer mice move into the cabin, it is essentially
creating a habitat 'island.' Maybe by leaving some brush to make
that 'island' more continuous with the rest of the habitat, you
might reduce the density of deer mice" near and inside the cabin.
Dearing plans
to apply to the National Institutes of Health for a five-year grant
of $650,000 to test the hypothesis that ORV damage to the landscape
increases hantavirus prevalence among deer mice. If the funding
is approved, she plans to compare hantavirus infection rates in
rodents in undisturbed and disturbed areas.
|